Comparison · PII proxy vs evidence gateway

A PII proxy redacts text. Talon proves governance.

A PII proxy can be a useful narrow control. Talon’s 2.0 wedge is wider and more defensible: EU-sovereign egress control, pre-spend cost policy, tool governance, provider routing, and signed evidence for auditor review.

PII proxy
  ✓ scan text
  ✓ redact text
  ✗ prove provider routing
  ✗ enforce cost before spend
  ✗ govern tools / MCP
  ✗ sign auditor evidence

Talon
  ✓ evidence-grade AI traffic control
PII is one controlEvidence is the wedgeEU egress mattersCost before spendTools need policy

Core difference

Redaction is not a governance record.

Talon 2.0 should not be described as a better PII proxy. The sharper claim is that Talon turns AI traffic into signed evidence: who called, what data was detected, which policy ran, where traffic was allowed to go, what it cost, and whether the record still verifies.

🔐

PII proxy scope

Mostly request or response text scanning and masking.

🛡️

Talon gateway scope

Caller, tenant, policy, PII, model, cost, provider, sovereignty, tools, and evidence.

🧾

Buyer proof

Export signed records and verify integrity with talon audit verify.

Comparison

PII proxy vs Talon 2.0.

CapabilityPII proxyTalon
Request/response PII scanYesYes, with EU-focused recognizers
Redact sensitive textYesYes
Caller and tenant policyUsually partialYes
Pre-spend cost capsNo / not primaryYes
EU provider routing postureNo / not primaryYes
Model allowlist by data tierNo / not primaryYes
Tool and MCP governanceNoYes
Signed evidence recordNoHMAC-signed
Auditor exportDepends on implementationCSV / JSON / signed export

When to use each

Pick a PII proxy only when the problem is only redaction.

Use a PII proxy if the buyer only needs to mask sensitive strings. Use Talon when the buyer must prove governed AI traffic for a customer, DPO, security, board, or auditor review.

Use Talon when the buyer asks:

- What data left?
- Where did it go?
- Which policy allowed it?
- Was spend capped before the call?
- Which tools were exposed?
- Can you verify the record?

Practical test

Run one PII-bearing request through Talon.

Send a request with test PII, inspect the decision, export the evidence, and verify the signature.